Logo banner reading 'An affiliate of Andersen Consulting' with a curved swoosh and a door illustration on the right.
Home › Solutions › Leadership Coaching › People Who Think They’re Great Coaches Often Aren’t

Article

People Who Think They’re Great Coaches Often Aren’t

Many leaders who think they are good coaches aren't. Among 3,761 leaders, the 24% who overrated their coaching skills scored at just the 32nd percentile, and seven common traits, including poor listening, explain why.
Older woman teaching at a whiteboard of equations

“I think I am a pretty good coach,” the executive across the desk said to us.

Impressed with his positive attitude about himself, we asked, “How do you know?”

He said he had attended a coaching course and learned many of the techniques of good coaching. That triggered a question for us. How many leaders believe they are better coaches than they really are? After all, the most critical test for measuring your effectiveness as a coach lies not in your belief about your own skills but rather on how the recipients of your coaching rate your skills (and on how their own competencies increase afterward).

We examined data on 3,761 leaders who assessed their own coaching skills and had the courage, afterward, to have others give them assessments as well. We analyzed those who overrated their coaching skills and compared the results with those who’d underrated.

What we found: 24% of the leaders in our sample had overrated their skills. Just as many adults believe they are far above average in their driving skills or in possessing common sense, this group believed they were above-average coaches.

We were curious about the effect of this overrating. The graph below shows the results. On average, those who underrated their skills were above average in their overall coaching effectiveness (reaching the 57th percentile). Those who had overrated themselves, however, were significantly below average, reaching only the 32nd percentile. This phenomenon was described by two Cornell psychologists, David Dunning and Justin Kruger, who observed that for any given skill, incompetent people fail to recognize their own deficiencies and don’t recognize the skill in others. The lower an individual is on any scale of measurement, the more out-of-touch they tend to become.

W160617_ZENGER_LEADERWHO

This means that those who overrated their abilities were in the bottom third, as viewed by others. In other words, if you think you’re a good coach but you actually aren’t, this data suggests you may be a good deal worse than you imagined. Bursting the bubble of your illusion of superiority could be highly advantageous to your continued development as a leader. In fact, this is the best reason to find a way to obtain honest feedback about your coaching skills.

The second reason to do so is to find out where, specifically, you could most improve in your coaching skills. Our data identified seven characteristics of those who overestimated their abilities most frequently. Do any of these apply to you?

  • Poor listening. Few people describe themselves as poor listeners. True effectiveness of a listener relies on the perceptions of others. Effective listeners do it without judgment, have a strong desire to understand, and are willing to take the time to hear about the needs and concerns of others. An important test of being an effective listener is what your response is to feedback from others. If you get defensive and resist the feedback, you will not be perceived as an effective listener.
  • Not a role model. Effective coaches are trusted and viewed as role models. The best coaches create an open, trusting environment by initiating positive interactions with others. Giving credit to others and looking for opportunities to recognize and praise others increases trust.
  • Not collaborative. Effective coaches look for opportunities to cooperate and collaborate with others. Ineffective coaches, conversely, are competitive. Less-effective coaches look for opportunities to make themselves or their teams look good in front of others. They compete for resources and believe there are winners and losers in the organization.
  • Don’t develop others. Great coaches help others develop new skills and prepare them for future opportunities. The reality is that helping another person develop new skills takes time and personal effort. Having the willingness to bring someone close and make the ongoing effort to coach them is an active demonstration of the desire and skill it takes to be a good coach.
  • Fail to provide feedback. The best coaches are willing to give clear, honest, pointed feedback about what people need to do to improve performance. And they do it in a positive, enabling way. Ineffective coaches either avoid giving feedback or bombard people with so much criticism that they demotivate and discourage participants from trying.
  • Lack integrity. Great coaches do the right thing. They honor commitments and keep promises. They do what is right regardless of personal consequences. Others know they will keep confidences. Ineffective coaches talk behind people’s backs. They say one thing and do another.
  • Don’t encourage diversity. Great coaches respect others and values differences regardless of age, gender, or race. They do this not because of laws or rules in the organization but because they truly value and appreciate the advantages that diversity brings. Colleagues feel that they care.

Coaching skills are a great asset to any leader. Becoming a great coach begins with aspiring to be a good one. If you have attended some training, that’s a good start. But don’t stop there. Assess your specific coaching skills — and have your team assess them too. If your skills are good, you will find ways to make them even better. And if you need to improve, the way to start is to identify those blind spots.

This article first appeared in Harvard Business Review. 

Download Zenger Folkman’s Extraordinary Coach eBook. 

Upcoming Event

JAN

12 & 14

2027

Virtual Workshop

The Extraordinary Coach™

9:30am – 1:00pm MT daily

The Extraordinary Coach draws on research and practical experience to help leaders become more effective coaches. Develop stronger coaching skills through greater self-awareness, a flexible conversation framework, and practical application that empowers employees to discover their own solutions and take action.

Read more insights

Podcast Oct 21, 2026

Your Feedback Is Too Nice to Be Useful

Are you giving employees the feedback they need to improve—or just telling them what they want to hear? Many leaders avoid difficult…

Listen to the episode →

Feedback Preferences
Article Aug 2, 2024

Leaders Should Reevaluate Their Feedback Preferences

Nearly two-thirds of 9,580 leaders preferred giving redirecting feedback, yet those who favored it and avoided praise were rated at only the…

Read the article →

Coaching webinar background
Webinar May 30, 2024

COACHING: The Skill Anyone Can Learn and Everyone Needs

COACHING: The Skill Anyone Can Learn and Everyone Needs Unlock the true potential of your organization and discover the power of coaching…

Watch the webinar →